Showing posts with label Consumer Christianity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Consumer Christianity. Show all posts

16 May 2013

Missional Ordinariness

I met with some pastors a few weeks ago to see if I could help their congregations begin the titanic turn towards missional. I’m not sure if I was a little too tired or what, but I found myself irritated and a tad ornery within the first hour. I apologized for my attitude but then proceeded to identify why I was getting a minor headache from our meeting. These well meaning leaders seemed to be fishing for the “big catalytic innovation” that would “unleash a movement”; meanwhile the ordinariness of a communal/missional shaped lifestyle was seemingly unimpressive to them. These pastors humored my crankiness and I eventually warmed up to their eager questions. 

I’ve never been more convinced that it’s the ordinary stuff that we fumble because our eyes are darting elsewhere. The most ground-breaking missional excavating is in the unattractive details of our rhythmic ongoing lives. Addressing these details will bring about a collision with the primordial-ordinary ways we need to recover dwelling in our communities.  I won't get into what those specific ordinary rhythms are (I have in past posts). I'd like to point out, sorry it might come across a little preachy, some observations that I sense are lingering underneath the surface. These issues threaten to make the dynamic of "ordinariness" uninteresting.

Image
One of my frustrations is the knee-jerk thinking “how are we going to spin this to create excitement in our congregation”. We are bit too tickled and consumed with making our mark. We could benefit from losing some interest in ourselves. Under the mantra of "casting a vision" we begin to push buttons to manipulate corporate energy. When we lean into “being missional” it should not be attached to larger presentations. This bent deludes the authenticity demanded of us in Post-Christendom. It also perpetuates the obsession with landscaping while neglecting the major shifts occurring on a plate-tectonic level. We need patience to wrestle first with what’s going on in the backroom before mocking up the display window. Image management creates "cool" churches with poser sensibilities. These sensibilities smell of self-importance to those not yet convinced of Jesus. Swaths of churchy-stuff has been paraded in public which inadvertently has eroded relational credibility on the street. Our grand language should lag way, way behind our action. American life can feel like an insane asylum pulsating with noise, technology, information, and competition. The church does not need to add to that sub-static buzz. 

Integrity
We all have the tendency to let our talk outpace our practice. It takes discipline to move beyond the viral chatter we participate in. Sometimes the missional conversation is reminiscent of my time in youth ministry when I'd eavesdropped on a pack of Jr High boys talking like they were Casanova’s. The Missional conversation is in jeopardy of merely hovering at pontificating status. We need integrity in our speech. Integrity is forged in testing. The best diagnostics and valuable conversations are squeezed out of real-time practices that have survived the harsh elements. In my own trembling faith plunge, Missional Ordinariness has taken me to task, tempered my adolescent exuberance and caused me to “bring it down on a notch” when speaking about how dynamic missional living can be. Over the years a more weathered passion has formed in my gut from the trial of submitting my ideas to a flesh-and-bone community. A good half of my ideas were half-baked and blinded by idealism. For example, I’ve been part of the multicultural conversation for years, advocating for racial reconciliation, but it is one thing to be passionate about an issue like a “diverse church” and another reality to build solidarity in trust-soaked, diverse friendships. The same ethic goes for “Justice”, instead of trying to drum up a Justice initiative that makes large sweeping projections, instead, loyally and quietly, immerse in a couple relationships with impoverished people around you. This ethic again goes for "community", stop wishing the people you've connected with online were your "community" and dive deeply into a spiritual family for hell-or-high-water.  It's honorable to want to “save the city” but it's humbled by learning to “love your neighbor”. 

Impact
The word “impact” has connotations of a meteor slamming into a region, leaving a massive hole behind. Instead redefine success around sustainability. Don’t turn missional into a program, a weekend city event with a magnetic slogan or a sermon series to get things moving. Resist the urge. This is Pseudo-activity and is only cosmetic.  I relate with an imagination that longs to be part of something significant but I’ve observed how our dreams cause us to brush off the most essential ordinary habits needed. It takes a certain measure of rebellion to fight off the undertow to fabricate energy.  When we claw for self-importance outside localized community our fragile egos are exposed. Pursue self-awareness: Are we emotionally detached from our neighborhood? At this precipice in history, earthy traction will come from seedling communities that inhabit with a rooted, open-handed, sacrificial, unassuming presence in the wake of Jesus, the Servant King. Missional is not a four lane paved highway rather it's an overgrown dirt path forward. There is no missional fast track and there shouldn’t be one. It’s not a martyr syndrome I'm advocating, just a marginal one.  

It's not pragmatic to shoot for ordinary. We've been lulled into thinking extraordinary is where the real world-changing happens. I contend that the West is fried over on ambition; tantalized into comatose. What beckons us now is a supernatural, subversive ordinary; one where the mustard seed offers us a template for the everyday. Call out those little thieves that come to steal away your enjoyment of missional ordinariness. Embrace the ordinary way of being in the world.

25 February 2013

Substitute Community

I was fascinated by the elements of the Manti Te'o drama. In January 2013 this young football player was hoaxed as his online girlfriend faked her death. An acquaintance of Te'o confessed to orchestrating a hoax that lured Te'o into an online relationship with a nonexistent woman. How did a young man build a strong emotional attachment with someone that was not physically in his life? How did he develop a perceived relationship with someone who was not actively present? Something about this story symbolizes a cultural shift in how we've begun to quantify relationships. The psychological issues around this story had me buzzing as it relates to the formation of community.

Modern Symbolism
We face complications around the symbolism of community. What is it? What does our popular imagination say it is? What ideals do we harbor? What expectations do we import? Personally, my laser focus on community is directly tied to my take-away from the narrative of the New Testament church. If the temple is no longer the space that contains God, what is? 

The landscape of the New Testament letters exposes that community is the container for carrying the message of Jesus. Biblically informed community and American popular ideas of community are not the same. Time and time again I see the Kingdom framework for community collide headlong into this concept I call "Substitute Community."  

The Challenge

Substitute community is a deluded version of a common-life. Substitute communities do offer us an emotional return, a sense of belonging and a feeling of affirmation but my observation is that they are primarily delivered on “my own terms”.  The Manti Te’o experience is indicative of the story we find ourselves in. He was able to assemble some of the contents of a relationship without having an actual tethered relationship. To him the relationship was real, which is the point. To Manti Te’o the relationship was meeting his emotional needs. The challenge of building mutually serving, faithful, mission-sent, spiritual households is starting to become clearer; we must arrest back this idea of community from the grip of felt-needs based connections. Our learned behaviors from consumerism are spilling over into our symbolic definitions of community.

Commodified Versions

On the ground many believe they already have community because they have: Facebook friends that comfort them on a crummy day, blogs they follow that cluster them with like-minded people, books that instruct them without being in relationship, runners clubs, book clubs or any type of club they attend. None of these are inherently bad but having furniture does not mean we have a house. Community has become a commodity and we approach it the way we assemble our own custom meal from a buffet of options. The center for belonging and becoming has eroded and is being parceled out. It is possible to put together the semblance of community “a little of this and a little of that” and end up with a self-selected substitute community. 

What occurs gradually is that we find our ideological tribe online but we don’t have to live with them or persevere with them as we together submit to Jesus. Relationships operating this way inevitably turns people into pieces that can be swapped out and replaced. This is a hyper individualistic approach that is sadly not the exception but has become the norm. In this substitute community paradigm, my self-image is being shored up with very little, if anything required of me. We must ask a rhetorical question; can we really experience connection without the pain of compromise?

Subversive Approach

Kingdom-community binds me to a particular people, in a particular place, with particular rhythms, with a particular responsibility. As a Missional practioner I’m convinced recovering community should be a major point of rebellion for us. We are not on a mission to convert the cultural (Evangelical or Popular) slide from ex-carnate brands of community. We must embody new practices rather than hate on the cultural milieu. 

Our work of community should be rooted in the recovery of actual eye-contact, locality, regular availability, mutual vulnerability, shared mission and rootedness beyond our offenses. It is worth contending for. Kingdom-community is the space we create for humans to become more fully human. The life of God is intended to be tangible in the life of a Kingdom community; it is the new temple, the new home of God. Be prepared as you invite and challenge others to live into community alongside you, there is an awkward and frustrating transitional process from "Substitute Community" to "Kingdom Community".